Noodles

The C 230 is solid as a tank, but the Acura is more reliable. I am looking at a AMG
version of the Benz C called the C43. It will do 183 MPH. Speed limited to 155 in
the US and UK. The C230 (unless it is the Kompressor supercharged model) is a
dog in performance if it is the base 4 cyl model.

The Suburus are turning out to be long term problem cars. Great for 3-4 years and
then lots of stuff to deal with.

A two year old Lexus IS is an awesome car. It will run with a BMW and offer excellent
service and reliability.
It will also hold its value better than almost any car.

Another surprise is the Cadillac CTS. It is actually an Opel (German designed chasis)
and is a really nice driving car.

I would still lean you toward the Lexus IS based on all around things already listed and
they are sweet rides.

The Audi A4s and VW Passats are sister cars and have a great road feel. Not as perfect
in the reliability as a Lexus but incredible road feel.